Why Doesn’t God Routinely Do Fantastic Miracles Today?

Here’s the latest in the series of questions from skeptics and atheists.

Question: Why have we not seen God reattach severed heads, restore someone who has been burned alive, or regrow amputated limbs? If God wanted us to know Him, He would be doing these miracles all over the globe. These would be miracles difficult to deny. Until I see this, I will remain an atheist.

First, the Bible has many such miracles. We see God save people who were thrown into a blazing fire (Daniel 3:23ff), grow a dead limb (Mark 3:3-6), stop the normal pattern of the sun and the earth (Joshua 10:13), and raise the dead (John 11:43-44). There were many eyewitnesses of these things, up to 500 at once (1 Cor. 15:6) and some of the most educated people of the day….people who would pass the witness test of the king of the skeptics, David Hume (see here). Yet even these eyewitnesses did not believe.

The passage in Mark 3 and John 11 tell us an interesting thing. The educated leaders of the day were eyewitnesses of these miracles, and many others, yet immediately after they saw the miracles they went out to plan Jesus’ death (Mark 3:6, John 11:53). Why would they do such a thing, rather than bow in submission? Because they were more interested in themselves than in the truth, and more interested in going their own way than in submitting to God. Therefore we have no reason to believe that even if God were to do miracles today, people would act any different. Indeed, Jesus did many signs and wonders, but people did not believe.

Further, as Richard Howe has pointed out, I seriously doubt if any skeptic or atheist would believe even if miracles were happening on a regular basis around the globe. Say, for example, that every time someone had a severed body part, God miraculously fixed it. Every time someone wanted it corrected, God did. We then go to the skeptic and say, ‘see, every time a limb is severed, it is God that heals it.’ The skeptic would then say, ‘But that happens all the time, as a regular occurrence. That’s not a miracle from God.’ Such denial would be a safe assumption, because greater miracles than severed heads happen all around us today. People that hate God are changed right before our eyes and become lovers of God (see here). Yet the eyewitnesses of such regenerated lives dismiss it routinely, acting the same as the eyewitnesses that saw the healing miracles of Jesus.

Lastly, saying that we know what God would do or what God ought to do is presumption at best. We cannot be so bold as to say, as finite and sinful creatures, what an infinite and holy Being would do.



About humblesmith

Christian Apologist & Philosopher
This entry was posted in Apologetics, Skepticism. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Why Doesn’t God Routinely Do Fantastic Miracles Today?

  1. John Paine says:

    If seeing miracles was enough to convince us, then the Apostles could have been dispatched at the Ascension. But they weren’t. Forty days after the Resurrection, Christ told his followers, who all had witnessed incredible miracles including the Resurrection, to wait in Jerusalem for the Holy Spirit to come upon them. He then ascended into Heaven. They still weren’t ready. One week later, Pentecost occurred, and the Apostles were fully charged and ready to accept the Great Commission. God knows that it takes more than witnessing miracles to convince us–it takes God within us, not merely God before us.

    After all the evidence of love, power, and splendor that God puts around us, we still want more. We want some kind of customized sign. What does it take for us to get it? He gave us his son as an atoning sacrifice once and for all. To ask for more seems completely ungrateful. We have all we need from God–his blood in the form of a Savior, and his spirit within us. He doesn’t need to do any more for us.

    Thanks for a great post, with much to think about!

  2. Daniel Shepherd says:

    Yes, Thank you for the post – This is actually a question I get a regular basis from my colleagues. I don’t know how powerful it would be due to the use of the Bible however, the words/power of the bible will never return void. And, if they don’t like the bible, tough 😉 – Again, thank you.

  3. dwwork says:

    Great post, like we have discussed before atheists are atheists not because of lack of evidence but because they choose not to believe in spite of the evidence. David

  4. Roger Causwell says:

    What evidence? Seriously – what evidence?

    The, “He gave us his only son” line is anecdotal at best. Dismissing for a moment the medically impossible notion of an immaculate conception, what kind of a loving God would send his only son to be tortured and killed in the first place? More holes in this story than a swiss cheese factory.

    No, let’s have some real, actual evidence. A booming voice. Skywriting that tells of a volcanic eruption at exactly 2:49 p.m. local time on August 26th, followed by it happening. Something beyond myth and tale and conjecture. And something a bit more recent than 2,000 years ago would also be helpful in changing a few minds and hearts.

    • humblesmith says:

      You seem to have either skipped over the argument in the post or dismissed it with a wave of the atheistic magic wand. Your last paragraph is answered in the post…..you are asking for the exact thing the post gives an answer to.

      As to the question of what type of God would do such a thing, it is one that has a much better understanding of justice and love than we do. We insist on squeezing God into our sense of fairness which is usually biased. If we really understood holiness and purity and the crime we have all committed against a good God, we would understand the punishment needed to pay for such a crime. The skeptic puts God in a paradox: if He does not stop every act of evil we call Him impotent or evil; if He does we call Him a dictator that does not allow freedom. What king of God is He? He is one that demands justice for crimes against Good, then lovingly pays the punishment Himself, voluntarily for us.

      As to what evidence, my blog has many posts on evidence. A good start would be by searching for the works of Colin Hemer.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s